Hi all, Check out this story in the Washington Post about young teachers who unintentionally disseminate unprofessional photos or comments via social-networking profiles.
Several teachers in Florida, Colorado, Tennessee and Massachusetts have been fired or suspended for MySpace postings, and some teachers unions have begun warning members about racy personal Web sites.
Free speech claims don’t offer much help. The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that governments can fire employees if their speech harmed the workplace’s mission and function.
Tell Us: Do you think teachers should be fired or suspended over content they post on social-networking sites? And have you ever searched MySpace or Facebook or some other site for your kids’ teachers?
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!
Maureen
~
Maureen Kochan
ConnectSafely forum manager
|
dixielittle
Posts:
1
From:
Milwaukee
Registered:
5/25/08
|
|
(7 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 31, 2008 4:04 PM
|
|
I found the article interesting. I am viewing this site for the first time because I am taking an on-line course. I am a teacher and I don't think that there should be different standards for teachers tahn there are for the rest of the population. I think that the standards for the rest of the population is too low. I have never gone on my space but I don't believe sites than be pornographic should be accessible on the web. Children are much smarter these days and they will find a way to get around the safety sites. If only they would put half of their energy into their school work. I do believe in free speech just not on the web. Stores are getting better about not selling things to minors and I think the web is just too large of a space to police certain material should be in print or audio only. Basically, if you want porn than you should have to go to an adult store and buy it. This might stop some of the sex offenders because I know they have to be registered. Teachers or non-teachers should have the same rights as non-teachers. They have a right to a private life if they can find the time.
|
|
|
veb2k5
Posts:
1
From:
Washington State
Registered:
5/31/08
|
|
(6 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 31, 2008 10:14 AM
|
|
I find it appalling that one's first amendment rights end when you enter the classroom. Macarthyism, red-baiting, character assasination--no wonder our best and brightest loathe the idea of becoming a teacher. Have we learned nothing from history? What is next, cameras in our homes and bedrooms to show that we are morally pure and fit to educate our young? Is this an incredible double standard where our youth simulate 50,000 murders gaming at home and online, where whole nations of young people all over the world engage in all kinds of social networking including all kinds of activities proper society would consider dangerous and immoral. The end result of this sanctimonious, holier than thou police state will merely make our public schools fortresses of ignorance where teaching innnvoative, progressive, and up to date technology is impossible and openly suppressed. Welcome all the luddites and purveyors of moral correctness to our brave new world! These kinds of realities only remind that I couldn't possibly stomach being a teacher in a new life--not with what I know now. Sincerely, Victor Bradley
|
|
|
clv5
Posts:
3
Registered:
5/30/08
|
|
(5 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 30, 2008 11:09 PM
|
|
This is a difficult one...I recall a few years ago when an old high school friend contacted me and told me to go on Myspace. My initial reaction at 30 something was are you kidding, it's for teens. I went on all the while keeping in mind that whatever I put on there would be available for anyone to see - my children, mother, students, etc...as such it was tasteful. However, that does not mean that inappropriate things can't show up. Say your friend posts messages that are inappropriate...or your friends' profile picture and any threads that they've recently started for all of their friends to view can show up on your page if you aren't very careful. I stopped going on quickly after I realized most of the people who were my age didn't act like they were the same age. However, I agree with the wife of the police officer who basically said to try and educate teachers and others instead of blindly meting out punishment. Like it or not though, as a teacher you should be a role model and putting out inappropriate pictures/posts isn't okay. So I would be fine with something being clearly included in teachers' contracts that addresses this issue. If it isn't present though, we need to realize that we as a society are dealing with new situations and that education is necessary.
|
|
|
Dr. LukeLuke
Posts:
1
From:
Hamilton High School
Registered:
5/28/08
|
|
(4 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 28, 2008 11:56 AM
|
|
Aloha!!! This is my first day in this forum for a class that I am taking for professional development. This article grabbed my interest. As I linked to the article and read it, I immediately printed copies to give to two student teachers in my department. (I just handed them to them.) All I can say is that wisdom comes with age. Regrettfully the consequences of one's actions usually come after one has behaved badly. From the sounds of it, a few too many newbies are still caught in the angst of youth. Hopefully, the behavior and lack of wisdom that they have demonstrated might be something that they would frown upon if their students did the same. However, its hard to lead where you don't go. By that I mean if you want students to act wisely, you must demonstrate it even on the internet. The social-networking sites are dangerous for adults too. As adults, we must demonstrate wisdom. Consider the audience that maybe out there.
|
|
|
Anne
Posts:
507
Registered:
6/26/06
|
|
(3 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 27, 2008 4:26 PM
|
|
Thank you for your thoughtful response, Carver61. You're so right, I feel. It seems just about all of us, including students and youth teachers, need to be reminded how easily their lives can be hurt by carelessly or impulsively sharing info, photos, and video of themselves. In effect, there's a growing need for second chances at a time when they're hard to find! Tx again,
Anne
--
Anne Collier
ConnectSafely co-director
|
|
|
carver61
Posts:
1
From:
Illinois
Registered:
5/27/08
|
|
(2 of 7)
Re: Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
May 27, 2008 3:19 PM
|
|
This is the first time I have replied to anything so please be patient with me. As the wife of a police officer an mother of 3 (21, 18 and 14) I know that this is a very sensitive topic. We must all try to remember one thing: these very young teachers are human beings, prone to the same errors are own young adult children make. Unfortunately, because, they are teaching our children, our first inclination is to fire them, hang them out to dry, with no chance to redeem themselves or save their careers. Instead, we should be educating them on the potential dangers of their actions. Most of them don't think that their students and the parents of these kids will be looking at their blogs just to spy on them. Our young teachers are still coming into adulthood and instead of mentoring them we throw them into the fire, now in charge of teenagers that are only a few years younger than they are. Some of them are still trying to be "friends" with the students because they don't yet know how to do anything else. I think these blogs are reflective of this. If it is determined that a young teacher knowingly, intentionally created a site to do harm, then he/she deserves whatever they get. But I think that most are just using bad judgement (as we all do from time to time) due to immaturity. The school system that hires these teachers should continue to mentor/monitor their progress as teachers, helping these young teachers to make wise decisions, especially when it comes to the internet. They need to be reminded how easliy they can ruin their lives over what may either be a bad joke or just bad judgement, something that can be corrected by giving them a little more time to growing up!!
|
|
|
Maureen
Posts:
667
Registered:
6/13/07
|
|
(1 of 7)
Should teachers be fired over social-networking profiles?
Apr 30, 2008 8:24 AM
|
Hi all, Check out this story in the Washington Post about young teachers who unintentionally disseminate unprofessional photos or comments via social-networking profiles.
Several teachers in Florida, Colorado, Tennessee and Massachusetts have been fired or suspended for MySpace postings, and some teachers unions have begun warning members about racy personal Web sites.
Free speech claims don’t offer much help. The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that governments can fire employees if their speech harmed the workplace’s mission and function.
Tell Us: Do you think teachers should be fired or suspended over content they post on social-networking sites? And have you ever searched MySpace or Facebook or some other site for your kids’ teachers?
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!
Maureen
~
Maureen Kochan
ConnectSafely forum manager
|
|
|
|
|